EWAG42019 - OpenConf Peer Review & Conference Management System

Review

Recommendation:

Reject: Content inappropriate to the conference or has little merit
Probable Reject: Basic flaws in content or presentation or very poorly written
Marginal Tend to Reject: Not as badly flawed; major effort necessary to make acceptable but content well-covered in literature already
Marginal Tend to Accept: Content has merit, but accuracy, clarity, completeness, and/or writing should and could be improved in time
Clear Accept: Content, presentation, and writing meet professional norms; improvements may be advisable but acceptable as is
Must Accept: Candidate for outstanding submission. Suggested improvements still appropriate

Overall Value Added to the Field:

Check as many as appropriate

Reviewer Familiarity with Subject Matter:

Relates to the confidence you have in your review

Low
Moderate
High

Is this submission a candidate for the best submission award:

Yes
No
Unsure

Is the submission length appropriate:

Yes
No
Unsure

If from reading the submission you know who the author is, how different is this from earlier submissions on the same topic by the same author? That is, is it the same as or a slight modification of other submissions, with little or no new information:

We use these suggestions in assigning submissions to sessions for the conference, but not in determining whether the submission is accepted)

Totally or largely different from other submissions
Moderately different from other submissions
Totally or largely identical to other submissions
Don't know

Which of the following session(s) would be the most appropriate for this submission:

We use these suggestions in assigning submissions to sessions for the conference, but not in determining whether the submission is accepted)

default

Comments for the Authors:

Constructive comments to the author(s) would be appreciated.

Comments for the Program Committee (authors will not see these comments):

Reasons must be included for all submissions, because they help us determine what to do when reviewers disagree with each other.

[ Sample Review Form - Fill in and submit review by clicking the submission title on main reviewer page ]

Should your session timeout while filling out this review, log back in right away as we may be able to recover your review.